Will Companies Really Be Fined for Paying Men More than Women?

Presidential candidate Kamala Harris says that, as president, she will fine companies that don't offer equal pay.
By: | May 22, 2019 • 2 min read
equal pay

If Sen. Kamala Harris gets her way, federal pay-equity law would be strengthened and would also help fund a national paid-leave program.

The California Democrat, who is among a pool of candidates seeking the party’s presidential nomination, unveiled a plan on Monday that would require employers to receive affirmative certification from the EEOC that they are in compliance with federal pay-equity law, or risk facing a fine equal to 1% of their profits for every 1% of the wage gap that exists between genders. The fines collected would then be invested in building universal paid family and medical leave.

Advertisement




According to Fisher Phillips‘ Richard Meneghello, “This is the boldest proposal taken to date by any presidential candidate vying for a shot at the White House in 2020, and may spur the current slate of candidates to begin a substantive conversation about pay equity on the national stage.”

Here are the seven specific steps Harris proposes:

  1. Mandatory “Equal-Pay Certification” – First, companies would be required to obtain a certification from the EEOC acknowledging that they have eliminated pay disparities between women and men who are doing work of equal value. The only factors that would justify a pay gap would be merit, performance or seniority. Companies with 100+ employees would be required to obtain this certification within three years of enactment, and every two years thereafter. Companies with 500+ employees would have two years.
  2. Massive Fines – Businesses that fail to receive the certification or otherwise stay in compliance would face a fine for every day they discriminate against their workers. “This fine will be assessed based on a company’s average wage gap for work of equal value,” the senator’s policy proposal states. “For every 1% gap that exists after accounting for differences in job titles, experience and performance, companies will be fined at 1% of their average daily profits during the last fiscal year.”
  3. Public Disclosure – Companies would be required to disclose whether they are “Equal-Pay Certified” on the homepage of their websites and to prospective employees; public companies would also need to disclose this certification in their annual reports. Compliance reports would also be posted publicly on the EEOC’s website for all to see.
  4. Universal Leave – Harris estimates that the plan would generate roughly $180 billion over 10 years, with revenue decreasing over time as “strong equal-pay practices become part of corporate culture.” This money would be used to fund the proposed FAMILY Act and provide 12 weeks of paid family and medical leave.
  5. Advertisement